Recently, I strayed into a post about Spam on a Facebook group I follow called
Appalachian Mountain Folk. That post generated a lengthy and interactive string of comments from dozens of members of the group. I commented that as much as I love Spam for breakfast I love Banner Brand Sausage better. That naturally generated a plethora of comments about Banner Brand Sausage from people who both loved it and hated it. I am betting that this post will do the same. Banner Brand Sausage is made by Pinnacle Foods Corporation in Cherry Hill, NJ. They also own Armour which makes things like potted meat, vienna sausage, and other canned meat products. But neither the Pinnacle Foods or Armour websites even mention Banner Brand Sausage.
When I was growing up in a
country store, we sold a ton of Banner Brand Sausage and also ate it regularly in our own home. Banner Brand Sausage is a canned meat product which is sold under the misnomer of sausage. But it never takes the traditional shape and consistency of sausage as most of us know sausage. It comes out of the pop top can in a gelatinous round cake and quickly liquefies under heat. No matter how long or how hot you cook it the liquid state remains unless you burn it to a dried out crisp. The photographic serving suggestion on the can shows sunny side up eggs residing on a plate beside some sausage patties. Rest assured that Banner Brand sausage never suffered the embarrassment of becoming a patty. The printed serving suggestion on the can which is labeled "Sausage 'N Eggs" tells you to "Heat sausage; add slightly beaten eggs, and continue heating, stirring occasionally until eggs are set. Season to taste." I suppose some people actually eat Banner Brand Sausage this way and I did get a few comments on the Appalachian Mountain Folk group to that effect. But in our house when I was a child, and in my house today more than fifty years later, we cook it simply by putting that aforementioned gelatinous mass in a skillet, heating it until it liquefies, and simmering it until the consistency and color suit our taste. It is also appropriate here to say that the "season to taste" suggestion never came from a regular fan of Banner Brand Sausage. It is spiced with a variety of seasonings at the factory which are more than sufficient to make it down the hatch with glee and a bit of warm, spicy zest. Some novices will say that it is actually a bit hot in seasoning. I love it just as it is. But the real piece 'de resistance of the meal comes when you plate it with the other elements of a Hicks family breakfast. I like to fry two sunny side up eggs in a separate skillet, heat a can of store bought cream gravy, and bake biscuits. I place two open faced biscuits on the plate, throw the eggs on next, top that with the Banner Brand Sausage, and then hide it all under the gravy. That, my friends, is breakfast for an Appalachian champion who intends to go to the log woods, the cow barn, the hay field, or a mule breaking where they will be expected to work until the sun is over the yardarm before eating another bite. That breakfast will stick to your ribs all day long no matter how hard you work.
Naturally, every time I mention Banner Brand Sausage some neophyte wants to know what it is made from. Here is the ingredients list verbatim from the can: "Partially defatted pork fatty tissue, beef tripe, mechanically separated chicken, water, wheat flour, salt, less than 2% vinegar, natural flavorings, sodium nitrite." Of course, every person who ever read the can wants to know exactly what "Partially defatted pork fatty tissue" is. I am not sure myself and I have eaten many cases of Banner Brand Sausage in my time. But I figure that if you have ever been present at even one
Appalachian hog killing you have seen the fatty innards of a large hog. Now just imagine that somebody took part of that out to eat instead of making lard with it. God, I love to eat that stuff!!! If you ever eat it, you will too! It grows on you!
Getting back to the post on the Appalachian Mountain Folk group, there were numerous comments which were pretty evenly split into two categories, those who love it and those who hate it. But more interestingly, the comments seemed to be concentrated among a group of people primarily from Eastern Kentucky, West Virginia, and Western North Carolina. This region seems to be the area where Banner Brand Sausage has been most commonly eaten. The whole Facebook group thing and my own very fond memories of many warm mountain mornings eating Banner Brand Sausage led me to do some Google research and I found more than one or two comments and full posts about this delicacy. I found one post on a blog called Dave's Cupboard which had the title
Unspeakable Banner Brand Sausage. In general, I like Dave's blog a lot but he is dead wrong on this one. Dave is a man who has and will try anything purported to be edible but I have to assume, based on his post about Banner Brand Sausage, that he is sometimes a finicky eater. I also found a post called
"Canned Meat Review" on a blog called "The Ultimate Answer To Kings" which had this highly negative review:
"All I can say about Banner canned sausage is Oh. Dear. God. This is the
worst canned food product I’ve ever tried, and I’ve tried canned corn
beef hash. I’ve tried canned menudo. I’ve seen (but never tried) canned
haggis. None of those things are as horrible as Banner canned sausage,
which (guessing here) consists of 99.736% recycled fat, some wheat, and a
homeopathic dose of …never mind, let me just go ahead and print the
ingredients:"
Once again, I suspect that this writer is also sometimes known to kick his feet, throw food off the tray of his high chair, and scream "No, mommy!" at the top of his lungs. I also found a You Tube video under the title of "Ewwwwm, They Call That Food: Banner Sausage Commentary". I have no idea how three people as spoiled and uncultured as these can still consider themselves to be qualified to critique food. Actually, I just realized that the person frying the sausage in the You Tube video is wearing a South Carolina Gamecocks shirt. How could we expect anyone who isn't a Kentucky Wildcats supporter to know anything about food or basketball?
I also found an online recipe which calls for bacon grease to be added to fry it in after it has been mixed with flour and an egg. Rest assured that Banner Brand Sausage does not ever need bacon grease or any other form of grease to be added. The partially defatted pork fatty tissue will guarantee you that it will never stick to your skillet.
I am certain that those of you who know and love Banner Brand Sausage have appreciated this post about one of our favorite foods. I am also certain that many of you who have never had it might have stopped in the middle of this post and run whimpering from the room. But if you have any sense of culinary adventure whatever, go to your local southern grocery store or the internet, buy a couple of cans and try Banner Brand Sausage. You will thank me for it after you wipe your mouth and rub your belly.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Addendum: August 23, 2021
This blog post has consistently been one of the most often read posts on this entire blog and is actually Number 10 overall from 378 posts over about a ten and a half year period with more than 4,300 page views. We just had one of the most unusual comments on the post that I have ever seen or heard. A woman named B. J., in the comments below, posted that she had bought a can of Banner Brand Sausage at a Save A Lot store, took it home, and her husband made a sandwich from it straight out of the can, loved it, and they are going back to the store to buy an entire case. I have never known anyone, in more than 60 years of eating and writing about Banner Brand Sausage who ever ate it cold straight out of the can. I would love to hear from any of you about what you think about that possibility especially if you also ate it straight out of the can cold. The only way I could imagine doing that would be if I was on a camping trip miles from anywhere with only a can of Banner Brand Sausage and no way to start a fire.
The discussion on several Facebook groups which my re-posting of this blog post today, August 24, 2021, has been interesting, funny, and informative, and we all have B. J. to thank for that. It prompted me to go to Amazon, which sells Banner Brand Sausage, and to read some of the 830+ reviews. For those of you who have actually eaten and enjoyed Banner Brand Sausage, I would suggest that the next time you need a laugh that you go to Amazon and read a few of those reviews. It is hilarious at times, especially when the comments are from a person who ordered it, knew nothing about, and still knew little more after they either ate it or refused to do so. Bon Appetit!
31 comments:
I totally agree with your article about the fond memories of this product over the years. But, have they just recently changed the way they make it? I used to buy it all the time over a 30 or 40 year period and loved it. Now, in the last 6 months, I hate it. I noticed my last couple of purchases of it that it smells different. Also noticed the color now is too red as compared to what it was over the years. Not sure how to really describe the taste now as I only had one bite. Seems more "hammish" tasting sort of on the deviled ham side which is totally different from my 40 years of liking it.
Have you noticed a big change in it also recently? Taste and color? I'm in Virginia and not sure if its all made in a single plant and shipped out everywhere or maybe the subcontract it out to different plants in different regions. But there's no way what I'm buying in central Virginia even comes close to being the same product I bought here for 40 years. The change seems to have come in the last 6-12 months.
John, I have not had the same problem you are talking about but I only eat things like Banner Brand Sausage, Spam, Treet,pigs feet, ears, and tails etc. about once every six months when I feel a cholesterol deficiency coming on. I ate a can about a month or so ago as I recall and noticed nothing. I don't even have a can in the house right now but I will buy some and eat one within the next week to test your theory. So far as I know, it is only made in one location, either New Jersey or Dubuque, Iowa. As for the color, they could be adding some USDA FD&C Red 40 to it since the fat base of the product is rather colorless. But I have not noticed a difference. You can buy it over the internet but with shipping added the price is a bit steep. Let me know what you find out. And thank you for the wonderful comments and the endorsement for Banner Brand Sausage. Have you ever eaten that other competitor, Beverly Bulk Sausage? I never have and I would love to hear from you if you have eaten it. Also, how about Liver Mush?
Roger
I have had Banner Sausage many times in my 77 years on the planet and believe me the new rendition of "whatever" they use for ingredients is horrible! Go back to the original recipe without mechanically separated chicken and the new color scheme, also return to the original texture because this "stuff" is worse than "awful"! I have Beverly Sausage now, however, the taste is similar but not exactly as I recall Banner used to be before new the formula was produced. I think Banner Sausage must return to the original recipe or companies producing it currently must discontinue production. GO BEVERLY!
Pinnacle foods obviously are ignoring the consumer comments about their messing up the recipe for Banner Sausage. Instead of going back to the original formula, I think it is a good idea for the Pinnacle food specialists to end up being the only ones that will eat it!
Go back to the original recipe and advertise it as the "real original recipe". Beverly is pretty close to the original BANNER TASTE so I suggest trying BEVERLY,
I have just recently again tried the new BBS and believe me someone around Pinnacle must be reading these posts because the taste has slightly, mind you, slightly leaned back towards the original taste. Still a long way to go! Why? Can someone tell me, did this company try adding chicken (mechanically separated) and alter the taste that people for decades accepted as a poor mans way of having a good breakfast! I still think the only answer is to try and find the original recipe and "fess" up to a serious blunder when some dummy tried to do a stretch with the chicken and new flavor and pretty much destroyed what most of us "old-timers" thought was a good product. Go back to the original tripe and organ meats and make us all happy! OR, do nothing and I think Beverly will appreciate it very much.
Bonita Hill, that is absolutely wrong. Read the ingredient list. It is scrap meat from traditional slaughterhouses, chicken, pork, beef, fat & innards, waste meats, whatever got shoveled off the slaughter house floors.
Roger D. Hicks
My mom always used BBS to fix gravy and it is amazing. She would always fry BBS sausage in a cast iron skillet with a little oil and brown the sausage, add flour (Hudson Cream self rising) and fry for a few minutes and then slowly add evaporated milk. I was raised on this. While I agree you either love it or hate it, there has been a change in the original formulation within the last year and it is not the same flavor which is very, very, disappointing. When I go back home to visit my mom I always request she fix Banner Brown Sausage gravy, give it a try, you'll be hooked.
Banner Brand Sausage many, many years ago was an excellent addition to a good biscuit and gravy and occasional egg breakfast.
Then a few short years ago, a dummy decided to alter the recipe by adding mechanically separated chicken to the recipe and altering the taste. Well, this dummy made a big mistake and the result was a disaster for the content looks, taste, and quality. I along with many others have done everything except stage a sit-in at the plants to get the owners to go back to the original recipe. It would be an excellent move to recover this product to its original recipe we all loved in the '60s '70s '80s 90's. this latest recipe with the mechanically separated chicken is bad news. Go back to the original recipe or lets all begin supporting Beverly Sausage as a replacement.
Here are links showing the old (original?) label and the new one. Easy to see they have changed the ingredients. As Patriot pointed out, they're replaced all of the beefy ingredients with the mechanically separated chicken. I also noticed it now uses Corn Starch instead of Wheat Flour. I'm not a cooking expert here so I'm not sure that switch also altered the taste as drastically as the beef to chicken did.
Old Label:
http://myplace.frontier.com/~monty.fowler/banner_sausage.jpg
Ingredients: Beef Tripe, Pork Stomachs,
Partially Defatted Beef Fatty Tissue, Beef
Heart Meat, Wheat Flour, Water, Salt,
Less than 2 percent: Vinegar, Natural
Flavorings, Sodium Nitrate
New Label:
https://i5.walmartimages.com/asr/81b3339f-0840-43f3-b8f8-613ac815e751_1.2395c3e101ff3a3a543b6cf07a14e963.jpeg?odnWidth=undefined&odnHeight=undefined&odnBg=ffffff
Ingredients: Pork, Mechanically Separated
Chicken, Water, Modified Corn Starch, Salt,
Contains 2% Or Less Of: Vinegar, Natural
Flavors, Sodium Nitrate.
I am so glad someone else has noticed the different ingredients being used in Banner sausage. I don’t like it at all now. I want the old formula back!!
So I really tried to like it. the smell even before heating was overwhelming. I eat spam, potted meat,corned beef. I offered the banner sausage to my dog and he said nah, he even tried it. It's sad when things change for the worse.
I would love to see a coordinated move towards the BBS board of directors that oversee the products they produce and make a stab at getting them to return to the old BBS taste using the original ingredient list. I grew up eating this many mornings as an additive to a great biscuit and gravy breakfast. As I grew older I continued to enjoy BBS however, a few years ago a real scientist decided that they needed to add mechanically separated chicken to the recipe and destroyed a wonderful product! Go back to the original recipe and make a lot of people happy once again!
Cant find Banner in kansas. And many other canned items.
To "Anonymous In Kansas":
You can find Banner Brand Sausage on the internet at several sites. I believe Amazon is one along with WalMart and Food City. Look around and you should be able to find it. Have you eaten it in the past? Or are you seeking to try it out?
Roger Hicks
It makes my day to keep seeing we have old-timers that miss the original BBS recipe more so than they like the new recipe! I think strongly that consumer suggestions should cause the current owners of this product to really consider returning to the original recipe or, explain the real motive behind switching to the new recipe! Is it profit? Is it easier to resource chicken than it is to get beef? What has happened to consumer satisfaction? The consumer is "King"! I have very fond memories of getting up to a biscuit and gravy breakfast and a nice bowl of BBS. Give that back to us!
Lets hear it for a return to the original recipe for BBS and make many people happy in a world that currently lets big corporations think they can dump on consumers without hesitation. Well, let all of us unite for a return to our original recipe. OR, we can make contact with Mexico firms that can do the same, but call it a better "BBS". Get it?
Oh my BBS....I thought I imagined this product from my childhood in SW Va. My grandpa would have told me it was squirrel or Bar meat to gross me in a fun-loving way, out but that wouldn’t have stopped me from eating this with biscuits and gravy because it was my favorite! Even if I could find it now, I am not sure I would eat it unless they revert to the original version.
I bought a case of this product when COVID was making store shelves pretty empty around here. My wife and I tried it and were not pleased at all. Now I was born in Montana, and raised on sausage gravy and biscuits. I tried, I really tried, to make something edible out of this stuff, but the wife said no. We've searched for recipes to make it tasty, but really none exist. I remembered this product so fondly because of my childhood, but this is not the stuff I remember. I see the proof that they changed the recipe, so that explained a lot. Anyway, we decided that this case (and a case of armour potted meat will be donated to our local food bank. If they don't want them, I'll have to toss it out. So sad. I was looking forward with nostalgia to some good eats, but was sadly disappointed.
Hammer11, this new BB is not close to the original, however, try getting some called Beverly Sausage, which comes fairly close. I am learning to take a can of BB and in an iron skillet, on low heat let it just sizzle for a long time, after many minutes it will finally begin to firm up a little so that I can have my memory breakfast of BB and gravy, biscuit and eggs. I close my eyes and dream of those cold winter mornings having that as a young lad. It was good.
Hammer 11 if you are gonna give all that posted mest and bbs away į could use it im pope and me and my family love it and we struggle alot with money and good and we could use it So please let us no thanks for meeting and we love it but the old stuff Was alot better now i know why :)
I never even saw this in the store before. I just came across it at a Save-A-Lot store. We bought one can to try it out and we opened it up today. My husband made a sandwich out of it…cold. He loved it and even made another sandwich. He can’t stand “potted” meat and he really enjoyed this above any other that he’s tried. I tasted it ..not like sausage, but It tasted fine to me. I remember my Mom talking about making sausage with buckwheat after the pigs were butchered. I’m going to give that a try. I’m also going to try it with a country gravy since that seems to be how everyone enjoys this. And, I intend to go back and buy a case. It’s a good source of protein at a low cost, and it will add some variety to my pantry!
B.J.
I am the author of this blog and I have known and eaten Banner Brand Sausage for more than 60 years. I have never known anyone who ever made a sandwich from cold Banner Brand Sausage straight out of the can. I doubt if anyone else who has ever read this blog post has either. I cannot imagine doing that and I love Banner Brand Sausage.
Roger D. Hicks
Well B. j. Whatever you did to get your husband to eat a cold sandwich from the can of Banner Brand Sausage with today's ingredient list is deserving of recognition because that qualifies you for a higher rating on "Believe it or not". If it was the old can of BBS with the original contents I would agree a sandwich of cold BBS would not be so bad. I think it is near time for a select few to get together, get an appointment with A Pinnacle CEO and take this recipe change to the producer. We need for a serious results committee at Pinnacle to either change the recipe back to the original or face a boycott that will hurt and at the same time encourage a strong committee to approach Beverly Sausage to adjust their canned Sausage to be 100% like the old BBS.. Right now, Beverly Sausage tastes much like the old BBS but falls a little short in total taste. I encourage all BBS fans to purchase 1 can of Beverlys and compare to the old recipe (if you ever tasted the original BBS) and see what you think of it. I certainly miss those tasty breakfasts of hot biscuits, eggs, gravy and a side bowl of Banner Sausage. Give it back to us!
Roger and Concerned_Ex_Patriot
That sandwich was his own idea. The next day, I had gotten out my buckwheat to cook and to try mixing it in…he had already finished the whole can! Seems that every time he wanted a snack…he made another sandwich. I wish I knew what it was like originally. I was expecting a couple of sausage patties. I’m still going to get a case..and I’ll be doing some experimenting. We had little money growing up and my Mom was absolutely masterful in creating tasty meals out of very little…and I learned from her. I’m going to look at this as a challenge to see what I can come up with!
I like to mix one can of Banner , with an equal measure of unseasoned bread crumbs .
Then one heaping tablespoon of corn meal . Then form patties and place in a HOT skillet with oil. After turning/browning the patties , I top with 6 or 7 eggs and lid the skillet to set the eggs .
AWESOME EATIN!
Banner is sold here in Bama Walmart's and I always keep a couple of cans in the pantry for quick breakfasts. I like to fry it together with leftover potatoes and onions and then top it all with Patterson sausage gravy - from Boone Foods that make Beverly sausage, it comes in small cans perfect for one - and then slide a couple of over easy eggs on top of that. With some hot biscuits with Steen's Cane Syrup you can't beat it for good eating on a cold morning with a lot of work ahead...
JDUB you are right on! What bothers me is the fact that many people that have eaten Banner Sausage over their lifetime all that have commented acknowledge that these companies disregard what people are saying about the "new" Banner Sausage. I wish they would go back to the original recipe that had an excellent taste, smell and look! I continue eating this sausage but in a limited fashion and I guess I am leaning more and more towards Beverly. I have written to the company but they will not comment!
I grew up eating BBS. It was a staple in our house. The first time I opened the new recipe I thought I had bought a bad can of sausage. It didn’t even smell the same. I got a spoon and tasted it and it tasted like potted meat. I don’t like potted meat. It’s bland. Tried to eat the BBS but couldn’t. I hope they go back to the old recipe.
Walmart Online was selling Beverly Sausage so I decided to give it a try since I was out of Banner (used the last couple cans during the big freeze we had here last month). It's a smaller but heavier can than the Banner Brand and it's made by Boone Foods too - the folks who make my favorite Patterson's Sausage Gravy (believe it or not WM's brand of sausage gravy is actually pretty good! Try it it). I love (and often make) homemade gravy (With Tennessee Pride Hot Sausage) but when you're in a hurry to get to work or out in the deer camp before dawn, canned is just dandy.
Anyway, I had some leftover taters so I diced them up, slivered some onions, and opened a can of Beverly. It's quite a bit firmer than the Banner Brand. I put it in a skillet and started frying it on a med/low heat till it liquefied, added a couple tablespoons of flour, some grinds of pepper, and then the taters and onions. Cooked till it was reduced a bit, the taters were browned and well coated with sausage, and the onions were golden. Meanwhile heated a can of Patterson's Gravy.
I had made and frozen a dozen Cathead Biscuits the prior weekend for fast meals so a couple came out the freezer and into the micro till nice and hot. I fried a couple of eggs (LORD have you seen the PRICE of eggs???? They were the most expensive part of the breakfast!!!) nice and over easy in bacon grease. When they were ready I plated the taters, onions and biscuits. Scraped all the Beverly sausage on top of them, poured on the gravy, slid on the eggs, and splashed with Texas Pete Hotter then Hot Sauce.
With strong, hot coffee, tt was a breakfast fit for a King and I was full till supper even with a day of cutting and pruning trees. I liked the Beverly Brand better than the current version of Banner, but I liked the old Banner taste a bit more (as I recall it) than the Beverly. I went back to the Walmart site to buy another 6 cans of Beverly (they had a limit for some reason) but all sold out... I'll keep an eye out for it though.
Well, that's it for my taste test! Thanks for reading.
JDub
Fairly new to banner sausage, but always willing to try different foods. Just drained some of the fat fried it to hot and added it to some cooked up zatarain's jambalaya and it was great.
Post a Comment